2012: Need it.
2011: Collide by Howie Day
2010: I'm Already There by Lonestar
2009: Little Wonders by Rob Thomas
2008: Come Home by One Republic
2007: Ellsworth by Rascall Flatts
2006: 100 Years by Five for Fighting
2005: I Saw by Matt Nathanson
2004: Homeward Bound by Simon and Garfunkle
2003: World's Greatest by R. Kelly
2002: Dreamer by Ozzy Osbourne
2001: Fire and Rain by James Taylor
2000: Desperado by the Eagles
1999: When the Leaves Come Falling Down by Van Morrison
1998: A Long December by Counting Crows
1997: Gotham City by R. Kelly*
1996: The Dance by Garth Brooks*
1994: Can You Feel the Love Tonight by Elton John
1993: Imagine by John Lennon
1991: End of the Innocence by Don Henley*
1968: Songfest